As Mr Gandhi said...

Tuesday, 22 January 2013

   
                             


        
  

According to the Daily Mail, (I know, sorry), in a study of 2000 mothers questioned, 90% admitted to feeling guilty some of the time with 1/5 of those surveyed saying they feel 'wracked with guilt'.

You can see the reasons listed here but the general reason is to do with questioning whether they're a good mother.

I think I've spent more time in the past 9 months questioning every emotion, behaviour and decision I've made than I have doing anything else. Even the blindingly obvious fact my daughter is a bright bubbly healthy happy little girl isn't enough to assuage me of the guilt that somehow I'm doing wrong by her.

Here's just a few thoughts that run through my mind:

- I must be a bad mother because I spend most of the day longing for nap time and most of nap time wishing I could freeze time.

- I am resentful at the huge overhaul my identity has endured - clearly I'm too selfish to be a mother.

- She doesn't have enough friends/toys/fresh air/stimulation/insert anything at all here.

- I'm irritable and moody often. She's getting old and more aware of moods. What if I f*** her up by being a miserable b****?

- I want to feel more 'useful' and respected even though I rationally think that raising children is essential, incredible and quite frankly, something majorly worthwhile.

Etc etc.

Okay so not all mothers are quite so self critical maybe, I know I've got some issues to sort out there regardless of being a mother.

But the point is this: It seems that in the 21st century no matter what decisions you make as a mother either for yourself or your child you feel like you may have made the wrong choice. And berate yourself anyway.

In the 50s and 60s it was much more common for mothers to stay at home and be good little housewives. Clearly a lot of these women were bored and wanted to work like men could. By the 70s and 80s many more women worked. As my mum pointed out, she was a lecturer at a university when we were little. It allowed for plenty of time to be at home but there was no guilt imposed or felt if you put young children or babies in childcare or had babysitters. It was generally seen as fine to go to work and be a mother.

And here's where I think the world is falling apart.

Just like capitalism is totally screwed up and the western world is struggling because we have no viable alternative, a parallel problem is happening to attitudes to motherhood. We are given the message both subliminally and more much directly that both being a stay at home mother and a working mother are somehow wrong. The working mother is selfish for needing more, the stay at home much not much respected for contributing zilch to society pretty much the same way as the unemployed.

So how exactly is any mother really supposed to feel good about the decisions she makes? Working part time clearly is the happy medium and according to How Not To F*** Them Up, Oliver James draws on evidence to suggest these mothers are the happiest. Probably because they don't feel guilty from leaving their babies too much but also get external stimulation that helps them feel more than just a mother.

So if working part time isn't an option what it a woman to do eh? In such an unstable and frightening global time it's even more important to try to feel and be secure in order to raise happy well adjusted children.

I've said it before and I'll say it again even though it's a daily struggle to take my own advice. Change has got to come from within before the rest of the world catches up.

I'd like to see a world where mothers are paid to stay at home and raise children if they want to. Just as they are paid to go out to work. Raising the next generation should be valued the same way we value all jobs. In payment. So here's my suggestion to western governments. If you're reading Cameron, which I'm sure you are, this is what I'd recommend.

Tax those global companies properly. Stop their tax dodging, offshore banking and so on. How is it right that a little business with a modest profit annually pays it's fair tax but companies like Amazon makes millions in profit and doesn't? Penalise the banks and other companies that do well out of the general public in good and bad times alike. Stop cutting benefits from the people who need it. If you tax those immoral businesses and super rich individuals properly you won't need to mess around with institutions like the NHS, or housing benefits for 23 year olds who can't get work. Share the wealth a little.

There's enough jobs to go around. It's just the 60 hour week executives take too much. No one should work so hard or so long so they can keep up the lifestyle they've started. If everyone worked 20 hour weeks they'd be no unemployment. and think how much better quality of life would be! Let's change this crazy gap between what the richest and the poorest earn, it does not make for a happy world, have you not realised this?

Pay women (or men) to stay at home and raise children. Payment will make it a much more recognised skill, and may well make men feel more inclined to do it. Let's stop seeing parents as scroungers, lying around watching Jeremy Kyle all day. Let's stop judging people by the work they do but by the people they are. If there's less of a divide between rich and poor then less value is given to the work you do and your social status will be determined more by who you are.

Communism might not have worked first time around but the concept of equality is much kinder, more sensible and fairer. Human beings should be judged socially by the strengths of their character, not what they do for a living, what car they drive, what clothes they wear.

Have I made myself clear Cameron? Good. Off you trot then to implement my changes.

Hahaha. Okay so I may have gone off on a little rant there but do you hear me people?!

This world we are raising our babies in is a mess. Worse than it's ever been. Most people are nowhere near as happy as they want to be, constantly striving for what they think will make them content. So let's stop. Let's take things back to their simpler roots.

And in the meantime, whilst we wait for the world to catch up let's do what we can to ignore the messages we receive and have a little faith. That we are making the right decisions for ourselves and our families. It may be too late for our generation but let's hope when our babies are having babies, all mothers, regardless of other jobs will have the courage of their convictions and be proud of the mothers, and people they are.

*P.S that quote has been paraphrased apparently but it illustrated by point so I went with it.*

11 comments:

  1. Wow, your list of things you worry about is EXACTLY what runs through my mind (on a daily basis). Thank you for a timely reminder that I am not alone in my thoughts as I embark on motherhood for the second time.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I know what you mean I feel the push and pull. I've been both a working mother (for my older two) and a stay at home mum now for my youngest, it doesn't matter what we chose there's judgement. It would be great if at home parenting was respected (regardless of whether it is the mum or dad at home.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i find that i'm doubting myself a lot and that is frustrating...like...sometimes i'm just like...omg, i'm putting him for a nap now and if he doesn't like it he will let me know so stop worrying if it's too early! you know???
    but you know what...i say screw the world and the small minded people who don't make a raising a child seem worthwhile...there are also a lot of positive people out there who do recognize what it is and what the sacrifice is and that is fine for me. the other people obviously aren't worth listening to.

    ReplyDelete
  4. only 90% ? i feel guilty all the time. basically whenever my neighbor comes by with her "perfect" baby ;)
    i was reading an article recently where it calculated what stay-at-home moms were worth and it's over $100,000/year so i would love to get that kind of paycheck. not that raising my son isn't rewarding in and of itself but, raising a child is definitely worth that money.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My biggest guilt thought is 'do I really want more kids?'
    I worry about how much more tired, busy sleep deprived I would be with more than one baby.
    Is that selfish? Or do other first time mothers think this too?
    I do want more kids though... Sigh.

    ReplyDelete
  6. thanks for share.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great post! I am with you 100%. I have based my whole blog on guilt (www.guiltymum.co.uk) as I am racked with it and I don't want to be, I try really bloody hard at everything I do! In my opinion guilt is just confirmation of how much we prioritise our children's happiness and I am all for that.

    ReplyDelete
  8. YES! Not enough friends/not enough fresh air/irritable/moody. Guilt, guilt, guilt and guilt!

    I was totally unprepared for this feeling, I'm intrigued by the 200 Mama's questioned who apparently never feel it...

    ps: well ranted!

    ReplyDelete
  9. <3

    I'm working on just going with things and not getting trapped in guilt.

    I think we all need to work less (or part time) both mums and dads and the child free. I feel our societal priories are so messed up, but I also feel like there's a change in consciousness around now (perhaps in the wake of the economic crisis)...I have a friend, Jack, who is fortunate enough to live on Kauai and is legitimately starting his own permaculture community - sometimes I seriously consider trying to join, and then I realise that what is possible in paradise isn't possible for many others and that what we need is change *here*, now.

    x

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for taking the time to comment, I don't always have time to reply but rest assured I read every one so thank you! :)

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

oh! you pretty things - a UK baby blog All rights reserved © Blog Milk Powered by Blogger